
Reviewed: 08/15/2026
Combined Rating: 4/5
Lauren’s Review:
I can’t remember the last time a film was so highly anticipated… in my household, anyway. We watched endless reviews beforehand, almost all of them from haters who claimed that the film was awful in seventy-eight different ways. Much of it centered around the woke casting choices, but then there was the modern dialogue (completely takes you out of the story!), the script was too self-aware, boring, uninspired, and also feminist (…feminist? Really?) But, we read The Odyssey aloud together, plus it was written and directed by Christopher Nolan, so we couldn’t *not* see it…
Honestly, I now have to wonder about all of these critics’ judgment in general. Seems to me that they must have gone in determined to find fault for some preordained reason—and of course, if you want to, you certainly can. As for me, aside from the same jarring casting choices everyone else is talking about (which really do take you out of the story, but they’re bit parts so it didn’t interfere with my appreciation overall), I think Nolan improved upon Homer a great deal. (I feel I can legitimately say this, because I’ve read The Odyssey twice now. While it was a decent adventure story, I found it slow, episodic, and with too little characterization.) Nolan’s pacing, by contrast, was superb—so much so that I almost didn’t even notice the film’s (admittedly absurd) nearly three hour length. By inserting the whole thing into a frame story, as told by Odysseus (Matt Damon) to Calypso (Charlize Theron), the story doesn’t get bogged down in a linear structure, but jumps around in time—from the Trojan horse and the battle at Troy, to just the highlights of the monsters and adventures on the high seas. Meanwhile, it interweaves flashbacks to Ithaca from before Odysseus left, to the present, as Penelope (Anne Hathaway) fends off her boorish suitors (of whom Robert Pattinson was most memorable), and Telemachus (Tom Holland) plays for time while trying to learn what has become of his father.
I also felt far more emotionally invested in the characters in this version than in the original. Homer’s Odysseus, while clever, seemed arrogant and unfaithful to his long-suffering wife—which was kind of just the culture, I think. Women were expected to remain faithful, while men could do what they liked with impunity. In this version, at least, Odysseus doesn’t sleep with Circe, just Calypso (for seven years)—but he only does that because Calypso drugs him, and he doesn’t even remember Penelope’s existence until just before he leaves. I also found Penelope and Telemachus sympathetic, Pattinson’s character cowardly and hatable, and the climactic ending satisfying and well-deserved. Yes, there were nits I could pick at here and there—but really, I think there’s been quite enough of that. ****
Frank’s Review:
Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey is not Homer, but its own unique beast that borrows the bare bones to tell a decidedly modern story. I don’t have a problem with that because the story he chose to tell was well told, productive, and even, arguably, moral. What it offers about regret and restraint is worth consideration, if not equally timeless. Chiefly, Nolan conveys dramatically that there are inevitable ramifications for how we choose to treat people…especially strangers. When we take it upon ourselves to flaunt the civil conventions that the Greek Gods were invented to congeal, societies, and even civilizations can quickly break apart. Next thing you know, we’re all “sea people” without even realizing it. Nolan understands just as myths and legends morph over time to maximize their culturally specific impact, the blanket truths imparted therein inherently appeal to most of us, or at least enough of us to maintain a fragile co-existence into the 21st century. Whether the “Trojan War” was about reclaiming honor or economic superiority, murdering an entire city-state seems an overreaction laden with unintended consequences. Very few of us could lop the head off a young villager without having that face emblazened on our conscience. As basic courtesies in our world get increasingly violated, I think Chris rightly decided it was high time for a refresher course.
Much of the pre-release criticism surrounding this film focused on “historical inaccuracies” and liberties that are sufficiently egregious to pull the viewer out of the story. While these moments exist, they didn’t compromise the premise, but in multiple ways, rather accentuated it. The diversity I initially lamented as being arbitrary instead served to remind that this is for, and reflective of, us, not people who have been dead for 1,000 years…even at the risk of pissing off modern Greeks, who treasure the source material as foundational for their national identity. But as much as origin stories are necessary for cohesion within, they can also be tweaked for resonance without. I mean, it’s not like any of this actually happened. But if it did, and the juicy scroll of deeds is one day found in an Ionian cave, I reserve the right to join the lynch mob of denunciation. Until then, I’ll probably ignore the two hour YouTube session bitching about how the cyclops actually had a beard and was a much better conversationalist.
Or, if you vehemently disagree with my quasi-pretentious blather, may I present an alternative theory to explain away “modern insertions” into the ancient period setting? Imagine Matt Damon (whom we all know to plagued both by self-loathing and delusions of grandeur) as a student in a Greek Mythology 101 community college course, who falls asleep during a feminist-tinged lecture and has the most lavish fever dream, choppy and chaotic, as dreams often are. The movie is his dream. The night before, Damon watched Monty Python and the Holy Grail, subliminally reminding him in the face of danger to just “run away…run away!!!” His kids call him dad, when they’re not stressing him out, and he spends too much vacation time trying to wrangle them to “get off this effing beach and go home.” His wife is out of his league, and he’s constantly worried about Ben Affleck, or maybe Batman, moving in. His dream ends when his redemption arc is complete, and he finally realizes if he just humbles himself and gives up control, being Matt Damon might be tolerable after all. I think it works in this context, and makes all the jarring “say what?” moments more palatable. I’m not trying to “out-Nolan” Christopher Nolan, whom we all know to be smarter than the smartest person we know, but in this dark age of cinema between eras of coherent scripting, is it wrong to ask audiences to think outside the box? ****
Meal Pairing: This movie was made for the theatrical experience (if any were), but if you’re re-watching at home, prepare a Greek themed charcuterie board with lamb strips, pita bread bites, feta crumbles, Kalamata olives, quartered tomatoes, pepperoncinis, and a side bowl of tzatziki and olive oil for dipping. Highly recommend some “Alpha” Greek Beer, which you can find at your local Pappoule’s (in Tucson).








